Guys can you help me out please?

I mistakenly scheduled two dates on the same night and now I have to cancel one of them. I really hate to do this since they're both such nice caring guys. I really like both of them for different reasons. Jack is funny and goofy, and very kind-hearted, and Brandon is also very caring but a bit more on the serious side even though he can be humourous as well. Well, see, I now have two choices. I can go to the Peach Pit with Brandon, or the Regal Beagal with Jack. I'm just not sure what to do. Which one sounds better for a friday night to you guys?